Introduction

Christians have long discussed and debated the theological significance of baptism; just as modern Christians differ, so did early Christians. The Gospel of Philip is a Christian text, likely written in the second or third century, that explores this in several ways. This text is considered by most scholars to be written by a gnostic Christian, probably one thinking along Valentinian lines. Christianity has always been composed of varied and different perspectives; let’s explore some thoughts from the Gospel of Philip on baptism!

The Gospel of Philip-- Valentinian Gnostic Text in Christianity

All quotes and references are from Marvin Meyer’s excellent translation, found in the Nag Hammadi Scriptures .

God is a Dyer

One metaphor reads:

“God is a dyer. Just as the good dyes, said to be genuine dyes, dissolve into what is dyed in them, so also those whom God dyes become immortal through his colors, for his dyes are immortal. And God dips those to be dipped in water.”

In this text, probably written sometime in the second or third century, the act of baptism is akin to dying a cloth. If the cloth’s colors are very strong on their own, only a very powerful dye will be able to change the color. Even if the dye is strong, it may not last if it’s unable to cling to the fibers of the cloth.

Being baptized, then, is like being dipped into a dye. God’s dyes are immortal– they never fade. And– here’s the critical part– just as a cloth dipped in red dye genuinely becomes red, a person dipped in God’s immortal dye genuinely becomes immortal. Dyeing a garment changes its essential properties (a blue shirt becomes a purple shirt, for example), and the same is true for baptism!

The White Dye

A later section in the Gospel of Philip continues this line of reasoning:

The master went into the dye works of Levi, took seventy-two colored cloths, and threw them into a vat. He drew them out and they all were white. He said, “So the son of humanity has come as a dyer”.

There’s quite a bit packed into this brief section! While we’re not going to discuss everything of significance (such as why the number “seventy-two” was selected or why “Levi” was referenced), we will touch on two:

First, who is it that is doing the dying? The “son of humanity”, or the son of man. Jesus, here, is the one doing the dying. Second, what color are they dyed? They are dyed white. This suggests the key value of baptism, and shows its intrinsic paradox: to dye something white is to dye it with such purity that no darker color or hue shines forth.

Dye and the Gospel of Mark

The Gospel of Mark has a related section in Chapter 9, as found in the NRSV:

Six days later, Jesus took with him Peter and James and John, and led them up a high mountain apart, by themselves. And he was transfigured before them, and his clothes became dazzling white, such as no one on earth could bleach them.

During Christ’s transfiguration, according to the author of Mark, his clothed became white– so radiant that no mortal could bleach them, no mortal could dye them. For the author of the Gospel of Philip, who likely had access to other early Christian texts such as the Gospel of Mark, baptism is that which makes us like Christ– that which makes us imperishable, in a way that only God can do.

Conclusion

The Gospel of Philip not only gives us a different perspective on baptism– the metaphor of God as a dyer, and of the dye as being immortal– but it also adds additional substance to a part of the Gospel of Mark. There is a lot more to say here, and if you’re interested, I would recommend you exploring it on your own!

Interested in learning more about baptism in the context of early Christian diversity? Maybe check out a Sethian baptismal hymn— it’s very different than anything you’ll find in churches, today!

8 thoughts on “Baptism… God Is a Dyer? Fascinating Valentinian Argument

  1. Curse those Gnostic Gospels and the Church fathers who banned them without care for the gems they hide! Lol, I very much appreciate this insight…and also a direction to begin some reading in. Question, with a premise–which you may choose to reject, If salvation is a process with baptism as a step in that process how does the idea of a process translate into this beautiful metaphor when it seems that the dying is, in a moment, complete and irreversible? Shortened: dying seems to be instantaneous whereas salvation takes time and working out “with fear and trembling” how do you see the two relating?

    • Hi, Speaker! Thanks for the great question! My response may turn out to be its own post at some point, but I’ll give some abbreviated feedback for now. I’ll approach it in the context of the Gospel of Philip (since that’s the context of the post).

      Let’s read from the Gospel of Philip 64:22-31:
      “Anyone who goes down into the water and comes up without receiving anything and says, “I am a Christian,” has borrowed the name. But one who receives the Holy Spirit has the name as a gift. A gift does not have to be paid back, but what is borrowed must be paid. This is how it is with us, when one of us experiences a mystery.”

      Part of the Valentinian idea is that some who are baptized are fundamentally changed through the power of the Holy Spirit (receiving the name as a gift). For them, baptism IS instantaneous. These are folks that the Valentinians would call “pneumatics”– I have several other posts on the site, if you’re interested.

      Other people are baptized, but merely borrow the name, meaning that it must be paid back. These are the Christians who must undergo “fear and trembling” as you and Kierkegaard might reference it. The Valentinians called these people “psychic”, referring to the Greek word for the soul, “psyche”.

      So, for the Valentinians, you’re describing one experience of Christianity– the salvation that must be worked out over an extended period of time– while the Valentinians argued that two forms existed (psychic and pneumatic), side-by-side.

      Hope that makes sense! Look forward to hearing more of your thoughts!

    • I’ve done some studying on baptism and the meaning of the word in many different locations. It actually is a dying process, which is to be repeated over and over until they dying is complete. I don’t believe the true baptism is a ritual or right performed in a church, but this process of purification thru a purge of a sort. And there are many references to three baptisms. Water, fire, spirit. My studies have found that water represents purification of the body, and I mean scientifically correcting the deficiency so as to unlock the DNA that holds the immortality code. Fire is the baptism of the heart (emotions) and soul. And spirit is spirit and mind. Creating a harmonious, balanced temple of the whole which Christ may enter. But also changing to the immortal. If you read the “Treatise on the Resurrection” you get a glimps that resurrection is something that happened to Christ before death. I have come to believe that the resurrection is associated to these baptisms of immortality. The only reason we don’t see people who have completed them is because of the extraction of truth from records. But if you can get your hands on everything ever related to the words of Christ wether you believe it is true or not and begin to extract the common threads I believe we can find the truth again.

      • jeffreymarfeo@yahoo.com says:

        I can help you with this. I cried out to Jesus and surrendered to him. Then repented and asked for forgiveness of my sins. Confessed my sins. Felt like my heart was torn open. Apparently thats where sin is stored. Turned around crying and had a rain cloud shaped as Jesus hovering in my living room. It was the Holy Spirit. Then maybe two weeks later my back was on fire from the inside of my clothes. When I went to look for the source of the heat. I saw a Golden band of light emitting the most powerful white light you could imagine. God turned my head away from the inside of my body no external force and came with the presence of Christ. So I would not be blinded. 1 month later my head went back on its own. Also with the presence of God. I felt amazing amount of spiritual energy being poured into me. A vision that night God filled my vessel with heavenly water. I didn’t understand what was happening. The Holy Spirit kept saying thats you Jesus and Nicodemus. But there is no light stated. So I prayed for wisdom and knowledge and Jesus spoke to me thru the Holy Spirit and said look the Baptism Gospel of Philip. So the lord took me out of my body and my soul and spirit are as white as snow pure white. And the lord spoke why clean the outside of the cup when you need to clean the inside of the cup. For you are a soul and spirit and need to be purified. If you or anyone have any questions text me. 914 462 1677. God Bless everyone.

Leave a Reply